Tithing in Modern Times: What the Bible Says vs. What Most People Think

 

For Christians across the globe, from the vibrant congregations in the United States and the historic churches of the UK, to the diverse faith communities in Canada, Germany, and France, the concept of tithing is often a topic of fervent discussion, deep conviction, and sometimes, considerable confusion. What exactly does the Bible say about tithing, and how does that translate into our financial practices in the 21st century?

The truth is, many contemporary views on tithing are a blend of biblical principles, historical church traditions, and modern financial interpretations. This can lead to misconceptions, guilt, and even 

avoidance for those trying to honor God with their finances. This blog post aims to cut through the noise, exploring what the Bible actually teaches about tithing and contrasting it with some common modern perceptions. Our goal is to equip you with a clearer understanding, empowering you to approach your giving with faith, joy, and wisdom.

---

The Biblical Foundation of Tithing: More Than Just a Number

The practice of tithing, giving a tenth of one's income, predates the Mosaic Law. We first see it with Abraham, who gave a tenth of his spoils to Melchizedek (Genesis 14:18-20). Later, Jacob vowed to give God a tenth of everything (Genesis 28:20-22). These were acts of worship and gratitude, not legal obligations.

Under the Mosaic Law, tithing became a commanded practice for the nation of Israel, serving multiple purposes:

• Support for the Levites and Priests: The Levites, who had no land inheritance, were sustained by the tithe, allowing them to dedicate their lives to temple service and teaching (Numbers 18:21-24).

• Care for the Poor, Orphans, and Widows: A portion of the tithe (often referred to as the "third-year tithe" or "festival tithe") was designated for social welfare, ensuring that the most vulnerable in society were cared for (Deuteronomy 14:28-29).

• Celebration and Worship: A tithe was also used to fund communal feasts and festivals, fostering a sense of shared community and celebration before the Lord (Deuteronomy 14:22-27).

It's crucial to note that the Old Testament describes multiple "tithes," not just a single 10%. Some scholars estimate that faithful Israelites would have given closer to 20-23% of their income, encompassing these various purposes. The Old Testament tithe was primarily an agricultural offering (of produce and livestock) for a theocratic nation.

What Most People Think (Old Testament): Many people, particularly in the United States and the UK, associate tithing primarily with the Mosaic Law, viewing it as a strict 10% of their gross income that must go to a specific religious institution. There's often a legalistic undertone, emphasizing obligation and the fear of God's displeasure if one fails to tithe.

What the Bible Says (Old Testament Truth): The Old Testament tithe was a comprehensive system for funding the government (the priesthood), supporting the poor, and facilitating communal worship in ancient Israel. While the principle of giving a dedicated portion is clear, the exact legalistic framework was specific to the Old Covenant. It demonstrated a recognition of God's ownership and a commitment to His purposes.

---

Tithing in the New Testament: A New Covenant Perspective

When we transition to the New Testament, the explicit command to tithe 10% is conspicuously absent. Jesus affirmed the principle of tithing in Matthew 23:23, but He also condemned the Pharisees for tithing meticulously while neglecting justice, mercy, and faithfulness—highlighting that the heart behind giving matters more than the mere act.

The early church, living under the New Covenant of grace, embraced a different paradigm of giving. Instead of a legalistic percentage, the emphasis shifted to joyful, sacrificial, and proportional giving, motivated by love for Christ and the needs of the community.

• 2 Corinthians 9:7: "Each of you should give what you have decided in your heart to give, not reluctantly or under compulsion, for God loves a cheerful giver."

• Acts 2:44-45: "All the believers were together and had everything in common. They sold property and possessions to give to anyone who had need."

• 1 Corinthians 16:2: "On the first day of every week, each one of you should set aside a sum of money in proportion to your income, saving it up, so that when I come no collections will have to be made."

The New Testament highlights several key aspects of giving:

• Proportionality: Give "in proportion to your income" (1 Corinthians 16:2). This implies that those who earn more should give more.

• Cheerfulness: Giving should be "not reluctantly or under compulsion" but with a joyful heart (2 Corinthians 9:7).

• Sacrifice: The Macedonian churches, though poor, "overflowed in a wealth of generosity" (2 Corinthians 8:2). Their giving was sacrificial.

• Purpose: Giving in the early church supported apostles, helped the poor, and spread the Gospel.

What Most People Think (New Testament): Many American and British Christians, and indeed believers in Canada, Germany, and France, often feel a strong obligation to tithe 10% of their gross income. They might believe that failure to do so is "robbing God" (Malachi 3:8) or that it's a prerequisite for receiving God's blessings. The phrase "storehouse tithing" (giving exclusively to one's local church) is also a common interpretation.

What the Bible Says (New Testament Truth): The New Testament elevates giving beyond a legalistic percentage to a matter of the heart. While 10% remains a good starting point and a benchmark established in scripture, the emphasis is on generous, cheerful, sacrificial giving that flows from gratitude for Christ's ultimate sacrifice. 

The "storehouse" concept often points to supporting the local church, which is indeed a vital purpose for Christian giving, but it doesn't necessarily exclude giving to other ministries or directly to those in need. 

The "robbing God" verse from Malachi is an Old Testament warning to Israel about failing to uphold their covenant responsibilities, which included providing for the priesthood and temple. While the principle of honoring God with our resources remains, interpreting it purely through the lens of a specific 10% percentage for New Testament believers can miss the broader context of grace.

---

Common Misconceptions vs. Biblical Realities

Let's address some of the most prevalent misunderstandings about tithing in modern Christian circles.

Misconception 1: Tithing is exclusively 10% of your gross income, no exceptions.

Biblical Reality: While 10% is a consistent figure in the Old Testament, the New Testament emphasizes proportional giving based on income and ability, motivated by a cheerful heart, rather than a rigid legalistic command. For some, 10% might be a sacrificial stretch; for others, it might be a minimal expression of generosity. 

The principle is to give generously and systematically. For a young professional in the United States, 10% of gross income might be difficult, but 10% of net might be a more achievable starting point, with a heart to increase. The discussion shouldn't be about legalism but about faithful stewardship.

Misconception 2: You must tithe to your local church (the "storehouse") exclusively.

Biblical Reality: The Old Testament "storehouse" was the central treasury of the temple, supporting the Levites and the nation's spiritual life. In the New Testament, giving was directed to support apostles, the local church, and to help believers in need (e.g., the collection for Jerusalem in Acts and 1 Corinthians). 

While supporting your local church is absolutely crucial for its ministry and mission, the New Testament also demonstrates broader applications for giving, including supporting missionaries, ministries, and individuals in need. An American or British Christian might divide their giving, supporting their church primarily but also contributing to other faith-based charities they feel called to.

Misconception 3: Tithing guarantees financial blessing from God.

Biblical Reality: Malachi 3:10 (the "test me in this" verse) is often quoted to suggest a direct transactional relationship: give 10%, and God will pour out financial blessings. While God does promise to bless those who are generous and obedient, New Testament giving is rooted in grace and love, not in a prosperity gospel mentality. God's blessings are not always financial, and they often manifest as peace, joy, spiritual growth, and the ability to be generous. 

For Christians in financially stable nations like Canada or Germany, this might be a subtle spiritual blessing rather than a sudden windfall. For others facing poverty, it might be the peace of knowing God provides enough. The motivation for giving should be love for God, not a desire for a return on investment.

Misconception 4: If you don't tithe, you are "robbing God" and are under a curse.

Biblical Reality: This concept comes directly from Malachi 3:8-9, spoken to ancient Israel under the Old Covenant. While the principle of honoring God with our finances is timeless, applying the "curse" directly to New Testament believers who struggle with the 10% can be misleading and legalistic. 

Under the New Covenant, we are saved by grace through faith, not by works of the law, including tithing. God desires a generous heart far more than a grudging compliance with a percentage. For those in countries like France, where faith is often more private, understanding this distinction is key to avoiding guilt-driven giving.

Misconception 5: Tithing only applies to gross income (before taxes and deductions).

Biblical Reality: The Bible doesn't explicitly define "income" as gross or net. In an agrarian society, "firstfruits" were given from the harvest before any processing. In modern economies, particularly in the U.S. and UK with complex tax systems, this can be a nuanced decision. 

The spirit of the law, however, suggests giving from the first and best of what God provides. Whether that's gross or net is often a personal conviction, decided between an individual and God, often in consultation with their local church leadership or a wise financial mentor. The key is to be consistent and to give proportionally and generously from what you truly possess.

---

Practical Application for Modern Christians

So, how should a Christian in the United States, the UK, Canada, Germany, or France approach tithing and giving today?

1. Start with the Heart: Before any calculation, examine your heart. Is your giving motivated by love, gratitude, and a desire to honor God? Or is it driven by guilt, obligation, or a hope for personal gain? (2 Corinthians 9:7)

2. Aim for Proportionality and Generosity: The New Testament encourages giving "in proportion to your income." For many, 10% is an excellent starting point and a powerful act of faith. For some, it might be more, for others, it might be a goal to work towards. The goal isn't just a percentage, but generous, sacrificial giving from a cheerful heart.

3. Prioritize Your Local Church: The "storehouse" principle still holds weight in supporting the local body of Christ, which is responsible for spreading the Gospel, discipling believers, and serving the community. Your primary giving should typically be directed here.

4. Consider Other Ministries: Beyond your local church, prayerfully consider giving to other ministries, missions, or individuals in need that align with your values and God's call on your heart.

5. Budget for Giving: Don't let giving be an afterthought. Incorporate it into your budget as a "firstfruits" offering. For many American families, this means setting up automatic transfers for their tithe, ensuring consistency.

6. Seek Wise Counsel: If you're struggling with questions about tithing or financial stewardship, talk to your pastor, a trusted spiritual mentor, or a Christian financial advisor. They can offer guidance tailored to your specific situation, whether you are in the UK or Canada.

7. Trust God's Provision: Ultimately, giving is an act of trust. Trust that God, who owns everything, will continue to provide for your needs as you faithfully steward His resources.

---

Conclusion

Tithing in modern times is not about a rigid legalistic adherence to an Old Testament law, but about embracing a New Testament paradigm of generous, cheerful, and proportional giving rooted in love for Christ. While the 10% remains a powerful benchmark and a testament to God's ownership, the emphasis is on the heart of the giver and the willingness to honor God with our best.

Whether you're an American professional, a British retiree, or a Christian navigating finances in Germany or France, understanding these biblical truths frees us from misconceptions and empowers us to give with joy and purpose. By aligning our financial stewardship with God's wisdom, we not only contribute to His Kingdom but also cultivate a deeper trust in Him as our ultimate provider. Let your giving be an act of worship, reflecting a heart transformed by grace.